Catholic Answers apologist, Jimmy Akin, explains the same in greater detail in his blog on intrinsic evil http: Coincidentally, I found while digging through my old work, of course an essay that I wrote a few years ago debating that very topic.
In conclusion, I think that how you get to the end matters more than the end itself. To change His pattern in these areas is to disobey His law. Others justify killing an elderly or seriously ill person - or helping them kill themselves - if it helps them escape suffering and avoid being a burden to others.
In my opinion, those are not the best ways to reach a goal. But they set aside God's way of being righteous and pursued their own way of being right. The proverb, a very disputable one, means that if the goal is good the methods adopted for achieving it do not matter.
The hypothetical nature of the inquiry and the doubtful causal assumptions you would not have saved the lives otherwise, only torture would have worked, etc.
There are acts which, in and of themselves, independently of circumstances and intentions, are always gravely illicit by reason of their object; such as blasphemy and perjury, murder and adultery. This is how modernism sabotages the pro-life movement from within!
People enjoy it, so it can be used to lead young people and indifferent people to enjoy worship. Many times, you have no choice. God is intimately involved in and in control over His creation. And would the world that was saved be justified in taking the life of the one who had just saved them?
Noah not only built an ark, he also used the material God commanded. The same action of engaging in a sexual embrace can be adultery in one context, but a blessed marital act in another. But what were your means?
Bible Examples Consider some people in the Bible who had to learn that pursuing what they thought were good ends did not justify using means that differed from what God had instructed.
Not a good way to go. So had Noah used a saw to cut the wood or a cart to haul it, he would have been doing right. To achieve that goal an effective method should be adopted.
He was cleansed only when he sought the end according to God's means. But note that a doctrine is human if it differs in any way from what God, whether in the end or the means. So, the end justifies the means.
Web sites may link to this page but not reproduce it. That is, until they find out that you cheated, which they most likely will. Surely, one needs not be a moral theologian to be able to distinguish the aforementioned evil acts from the just act of punishing only the guilty to a proportionate i.
Surely we ought to be able to find the idea taught in Scripture if it is correct?The End Justifies The Means. The End Justifies The Means.: An enterprise can succeed only if it has a goal. To achieve that goal an effective method should be adopted. The method can be harmless with no violence in it.
Or it can be hard and cruel which calls for a lot of.
The End Does Not Justify The Mean Essay Sample. The end does not justify the mean ” What does it really mean ??? How you go about doing something is as important as what you end up doing.
Does the End Justify the Means Essay examples. Words Jan 13th, 6 Pages. Show More. Lesley Rawlins The end justifies the means The end justifies the means is an expression that is often used in society to validate or excuse distasteful and objectionable actions undertaken by its people.
Essay. Does Rape Justify Abortion? Rape is a. The ‘end justify the means’ is a philosophical maxim popularized by Niccolo Machiavelli during the renaissance era. This maxim is supposed to justify the actions of a leader or what Machiavelli calls ‘the Prince’, to do whatever is in his power in so far as the ‘end/s’ justifies the ‘means’ of attaining it.
The question whether the end justifies the means depends on the type of goal or end a person wants to achieve and the means they use. If both the means and the ends are equally noble and good, there is no question because the ends are justified by the means. Thus, the statement “The end justifies the means” is two-faced wherein it can either be good or bad but it highly depends on the situation at hand.Download